Cultural Defense Accepted as to Nonconsensual Sex in New Jersey Trial Court, Rejected on Appeal

In a domestic violence case involving a Muslim couple living in New Jersey, a Judge found that the defendant did not act with a criminal intent when he repeatedly insisted upon intercourse, despite plaintiff’s contrary wishes: the defendant had told his wife “this is according to our religion, you are my wife, I c[an] do anything to you, the woman, she should submit and do anything I ask her to do”: the Appellate Court overturned the Judge’s ruling, writing: “the judge determined to except defendant from the operation of the State’s statutes as the result of his religious beliefs” adding, “in doing so, the judge was mistaken”.


Comments are closed.