For years, the women’s rights movement has committed to a slogan: believe survivors. Everyone who has worked with victims of sexual assault and gender-based violence knows that survivors carry a deep fear of not being heard or believed if they dare to speak up. The first and foundational step in advocating for survivors is hearing them and believing them, even—perhaps especially—when their stories challenge us.
On October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorists raped women, men, and children in Israel. Multiple incidents of rape and gang rape, including bodily mutilation and torture, were documented by survivors, first responders, and forensic teams. The U.N.’s own Special Representative on Sexual Violence in Conflict found reasonable grounds to believe that rape and gang rape occurred in multiple locations, and the Dinah Project concluded that the sexual violence was systematic and widespread. We know that many female hostages were also sexually abused in captivity, and those who were freed have since told their own stories.
But since October 7, the women’s rights movement’s slogan has had an asterisk. Believe survivors*: unless they are Jewish. Unless they are Israeli.
For weeks after October 7, major organizations dedicated to women’s rights and protecting survivors were deafeningly silent about what had happened. U.N. Women was slow in producing its very underwhelming statement. Suddenly, those who insist we must believe survivors were skeptical, not only demanding proof beyond what any victim would normally be expected to provide, but also suggesting that the evidence itself was suspect, when it wasn’t. Worst of all, many people, motivated by a hatred of Israel, glossed over the rapes and assaults and “contextualized” the attacks as part of a broader conflict in which Hamas’s actions that day were “resistance.”
Let’s be clear: there is no justification for rape, ever. Rape isn’t resistance. It is never necessary and never excusable, and it is always a crime against the victim. There should be no asterisk on it, ever.
Perhaps most egregiously, while the evidence of systematic, widespread sexual assault on October 7—a war crime and a crime against humanity—was ignored or denied, false allegations against Israel in the months that followed were believed unquestioningly and amplified by a credulous media. For example, within moments of the al-Ahli hospital blast in October 2023, the world was told that it was an Israeli strike that had killed hundreds of innocents, before it would have even been possible to make such a determination; The New York Times splashed it across its homepage. Evidence later showed that it was a terrorist rocket that misfired and the casualty count was falsified, and the Times had to admit it had relied too heavily on Hamas’s own claims. In 2025, a senior U.N. official claimed that 14,000 babies could die in Gaza within 48 hours—a fallacious projection—and the U.N. later had to walk it back as a mistake. That same summer, the Times ran a front-page photo of an emaciated boy in Gaza as the face of starvation, intentionally cropping out his healthy-looking brother. The Times later had to concede that the child had serious preexisting genetic disorders, including cerebral palsy, leading to his condition.
U.N. agencies and leading human rights organizations around the world have broadcast charges of deliberate starvation and genocide in Gaza as settled fact. But the details tell a different story. Amnesty International reached its genocide finding only after setting aside international case law on genocidal intent, calling it “overly narrow.” The U.N.-backed famine declaration relied on an alternative malnutrition threshold, not used elsewhere, that lowered the bar. When the evidence didn’t fit their story, they redefined their terms.
That’s not human rights work. It’s a judgment in search of justification. The damage is done the moment the false headlines run, often sparking violent attacks against Jewish populations and institutions, even if corrections are later added in small print to deflect liability.
All of this—the denial, the fabrication, and the dishonesty—was in service of a narrative that paints Israel as an unjust oppressor, and Israelis, and Jews more generally, as unworthy of protection and deserving of violence, including sexual violence. Demonize and dehumanize a people, and you create permission to harm them, and to feel good about doing it.
The irony is that Western progressives know that bigotry can be institutionalized: it doesn’t have to be in an organization’s mission statement to be in its practices, silently determining which voices are heard and which are dismissed. But after October 7, many progressives set aside their principles in general, and on sexual violence above all, in service of a bigoted agenda. In the last three years, we have watched antisemitism become boldly entrenched in the same institutions that claim to defend human rights.
Exposing the specific mechanisms that advance this agenda within civil society organizations will be laborious, but it is necessary work. We cannot fix a problem we refuse to acknowledge. That work has now begun. Last month, Florida’s State Board of Administration and fellow shareholders sued The New York Times, demanding the internal records behind its Israel coverage. And at the U.N., after demands for accountability, an internal investigation found that nine staff members of UNRWA, its agency for Palestinian refugees, may have taken part in the October 7 massacre themselves.

