Massachusetts Bans FGM After Seven-Year Push by Survivors and Advocates

Deborah Benson, the leader of Massachusetts Women's Bar Association's fight against FGM.

August 26, 2020

It took seven years for the work to come to fruition, but on August 6 of 2020, the state of Massachusetts finally signed a bill into law banning FGM. It wouldn’t have been possible without the hard work of the Massachusetts Women’s Bar Association, survivors, and other advocates.


When the Massachusetts Women’s Bar Association first began efforts to ban female genital mutilation (FGM) in Massachusetts in 2013, the state was ranked as the 12th highest state nationwide for women and girls at risk of or living with FGM according to a Brigham and Women’s Hospital report based on 2000 U.S. census data. Despite this clear warning, it took almost a decade for the Massachusetts state government to pass anti-FGM legislation. FGM-ban advocates faced difficult setbacks: legislators were not familiar with FGM, the fight often became political, and this spring, the pandemic consumed the world.

With grit and perseverance, the Massachusetts Women’s Bar Association (WBA), alongside survivors and other advocates, finally reached legislative victory in August of 2020. We spoke with Chair of the Women’s Bar Association Task Force on Female Genital Mutilation Deborah Benson to explain the grind of the process.

AHA Foundation: For the past 7 years, the WBA of Massachusetts Task Force on FGM has spearheaded the advocacy efforts to ban FGM in Massachusetts, with you serving as the chair for that entire time. There were many moments in this fight when it seemed we were facing a wall and our message to protect girls in MA was not heard—but the tenacity of survivors and advocates finally paid off. What was your reaction to the news about the governor signing this bill into law earlier this month? 

Deborah Benson: Relief. While the passing of the bill is a victory, the fact that a law like this is needed to end a practice that violates the human rights of girls is not cause for celebration.

While the passing of the bill is a victory, the fact that a law like this is needed to end a practice that violates the human rights of girls is not cause for celebration.

AHA Foundation: How did your involvement with this bill start? How much about FGM did you know when you started to work on the bill?

Deborah Benson: When I retired from my law practice in 2014, I focused on work advancing the rights of women and girls. This work included helping elect women to leadership roles in government, passing equal pay laws and laws dealing with parental leave, ending child marriage, FGM, and other human rights abuses. 

The UN had just unanimously passed the FGM resolution in December of 2012 calling for better laws and law enforcement. Curious, I took a look at the various state and federal laws in the U.S. and was surprised at how inadequate they were. Some states, like my own, Massachusetts, had no law at all, and given the necessary mens rea [the intent to commit a crime/wrongdoing], existing criminal laws could not be relied upon. 

I wanted to respond to this and my sense was to develop a comprehensive law in Massachusetts and use it as a model for other states to adopt. This model would treat FGM as a violent crime and a form of child abuse, provide civil remedies, training for first responders and education, and community awareness.

AHA Foundation: What were the hardest times for you in the fight toward the FGM ban in Massachusetts? How did you overcome these? 

Deborah Benson: Understanding the role that politics plays in lawmaking. Sometimes a roadblock has nothing to do with the merits of the issue. Also, understanding that there are many competing issues that are equally compelling and that the legislature only has so much bandwidth.

AHA Foundation: Were you concerned at any point during the most recent legislative session that the COVID-19 pandemic would cause Massachusetts legislators to put the anti-FGM bill on hold?

Deborah Benson: Of course, but I was also motivated by the fact that other states [Kentucky, Pennsylvania, and Minnesota] had managed to pass their laws protecting women and girls during this period and I shared that information with the legislators we were working with.

I was also motivated by the fact that other states [Kentucky, Pennsylvania, and Minnesota] had managed to pass their laws protecting women and girls during this period…

AHA Foundation: Despite determined advocacy by the WBA, survivors, and other supporters of the cause, the initial vote of the Massachusetts Joint Committee on the Judiciary in 2016 was a huge let down: the amendments that were made meant there were no longer criminal penalties associated with this harmful practice. What was your reaction to this turn of events? 

Deborah Benson: Obviously, I was disappointed, but 2016 was our first session. It involved raising awareness and building allies in the legislature. At that time, many, I’d say most, legislators didn’t know about FGM and, if they did, they thought it was not something that involved girls in Massachusetts, so we had an enormous hurdle to overcome. 

And remember, we were a group of volunteers. We did not work with a paid lobbyist. And we knew that passing this legislation could take many sessions. When we refiled the bill in 2017, we doubled the number of legislative bill sponsors including members of leadership, exceeding a majority in both the House and the Senate, so I believe we did our job of raising awareness.

At that time, many, I’d say most, legislators didn’t know about FGM and, if they did, they thought it was not something that involved girls in Massachusetts…

AHA Foundation: In the fall of 2017, powerful testimonies were presented to the Massachusetts Joint Committee on the Judiciary in favor of the FGM ban. This was an extraordinary effort by several survivors of FGM and a number of law enforcement, attorneys, and medical professionals. Then, in January 2018 the Committee made a shocking decision: they sent the bill to be studied which meant voting on it was postponed once again. What was your reaction to this outcome at the time?

Deborah Benson: Stunned. No one who works hard on a project wants to start over. But as an attorney, one thinks about not only how to present your case, but what obstacles or unintended consequences may exist or how circumstances may have changed. 

We needed to identify and address those issues in the context of the times. We had presented powerful positive testimony earlier in the fall. However, at the time the committee chair made the decision to table the bill, the country was fighting about immigration bans that included many heavily practicing countries. The political winds were not blowing in our favor.

AHA Foundation: One survivor advocate, Mariya Taher, spoke at that time of her concern that legislators pushed the bill aside because it was election time, as they feared it would seem they were targeting immigrant and Muslim communities if they gave their attention to the issue of FGM.  Do you agree with that assessment?

Deborah Benson:  I do think the decision was politically motivated at least in part.

AHA Foundation: How did the fear of being labeled anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim play a role in slowing down progress on this bill over the past 7 years and how was it overcome?

Deborah Benson: I surmise that, at least in the winter of 2018, some may have had difficulty—at least thought the press or the public would have difficulty—understanding that support for the civil rights of immigrants does not mean turning a blind eye to harmful practices. Ultimately, when we discussed FGM as analogous to domestic abuse or other forms of child abuse, the issue tended to resolve itself.

Some may have had difficulty—at least thought the press or the public would have difficulty—understanding that support for the civil rights of immigrants does not mean turning a blind eye to harmful practices.

AHA Foundation: The ban was passed with unanimous votes, 39:0 in the Senate followed by enactment in the House by a vote of 159:0. AHA Foundation believes that a bipartisan approach is critical in ensuring the successful passage of comprehensive laws that protect children against not only FGM, but also other gender-based abuses such as child marriage. How, in your opinion, could have legislators in MA worked better together on this bill? Were there any missed opportunities and are there lessons learned for other states that still have not banned FGM? 

Deborah Benson: I agree, it’s important to have bipartisan support and, in fact, support for the MA bill was bipartisan in the three sessions in which the bill was filed. Bills do not come to the floor for a vote, however, unless those in the leadership make the bill a priority. While it happened for different reasons in the House and the Senate this session, that is ultimately what made the difference. 

The Senate President, in her first term, was a true champion of the legislation. In the House, it was pure politics. The other significant difference this session was that the Federal law had been struck down. While we had highlighted the need for state laws, the existence of the Federal law made it easier for those in leadership to push the bill off to another session, especially with competing priorities like the massive criminal justice reform legislation which was addressed in the 2017-18 session overshadowing just about everything else the Judiciary Committee was doing.

More on FGM:

• What is Female Genital Mutilation?

 Has Your State Banned FGM?

• 11 States That Risk Becoming Destinations for Performing FGM

AHA Foundation: In addition to making FGM a crime, the new bill has provisions about education and prevention programs. How important are these programs; what are their role in ending FGM in the U.S.?

Deborah Benson: I believe educational programs are very important, however, if we are to protect the current generation of girls, laws must also be enacted outlawing this practice. 

AHA Foundation: Now that an FGM ban in Massachusetts has been passed, what are you planning to work on next?

Deborah Benson: Among other things, passing a similar law in Connecticut. While my home state of Massachusetts now has a law, my second home of Connecticut does not.

AHA Foundation: And how can our supporters help you in Connecticut?

Deborah Benson: I would say be ready to contact their state representative and state senator, but these are the early days and I think folks might be best to contact you if they are interested in helping in any way.

AHA Foundation: Deborah, thank you so much for taking time out to talk to us and more importantly for your dedication to banning FGM in Massachusetts.

Deborah Benson: Absolutely, it was my pleasure.

At the AHA Foundation – Founded by Ayaan Hirsi Ali, where advocacy for freedom and security is paramount, tools like OKX wallet are gaining attention for supporting safe and transparent digital transactions in the U.S.

Hacklink

hacklink panel

hacklink

Rank Math Pro Nulled

WP Rocket Nulled

Yoast Seo Premium Nulled

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Nulled WordPress Plugins and Themes

hacklink

Taksimbet

Bahsine

Tipobet

Betmarlo

Hacklink

Nulled WordPress Themes Plugins

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink satın al

링크모음

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Marsbahis

kamagra jel

listcrawler.us.com

github.com/gravity-forms-download

Betpas

Hacklink

toy poodle fiyat

Hacklink Panel

cialis fiyat

viagra fiyat

viagra fiyat

viagra fiyat

cialis fiyat

cialis 5 mg

cialis fiyat

cialis fiyat

vozol star 20000

Hipercasino Twitter

sultantoto

porno

Postegro

unblocked 76

Hipercasino

Hacklink

Marsbahis

Marsbahis

ürün teşhir standı

marjinbet

Marsbahis

Marsbahis

Marsbahis

ip stresser

Hacklink

ürün teşhir standı

istanbul escort

Dubai Food Guide

gologin hesap satın al

bullbahis

esbet

tantra massage istanbul

ptt kargo takip

casibom

casibom

afilta 20 mg

parobet

https://winbir-giris.net

betnef

betnef

vadicasino

pradabet

cashwin

betnef

bullbahis

jojobet

degra 100 mg

sinegra 100 mg

vigrande 100 mg

sildegra 100 mg

lifta 20 mg fiyat

flynta

Flynta 20 Mg

lex 20 mg fiyat

grandpashabet

casibom giriş

Hacklink

Hacklink

mariobet giriş

deneme bonusu 2025

samsun halı saha

pgslot

grandpashabet giriş

casibom

onwin

viagra fiyat

casibom

marsbahis

justin tv

marjinbet

ataşehir escort

instagram takipçi satın al

winbir

unblocked games

marjinbet hakkında

retro bowl

kamagra jel

https://unblockedgames76.pages.dev

Milanobet

printable calendar

bahiscasino

bahiscasino giriş

marsbahis

marsbahis giriş

fatih escort

intelon osint

vaycasino

royalbet

instagram takipçi satın al

bahis bonusu veren siteler

istanbul escort

bahis bonusu

jojobet giriş

süratbet

piabellacasino

elementor pro nulled

wp rocket nulled

duplicator pro nulled

wp all import pro nulled

wpml multilingual nulled

rank math pro nulled

yoast seo premium nulled

litespeed cache nulled

Hacklink

kamagra jel

viagra trendyol

alanya escort

taraftarium24

porno

best iptv

paycell bahis siteleri

lotobet

steroid satın al

terea sigara

click to play games

casibom

body to body massage istanbul

Массаж от тела к телу в Стамбуле

nuru masssage in istanbul

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Buy Hacklink

casibom

matbet

unblocked games

mariobet

casino kurulum

viagra fiyat

viagra fiyat

jojobet giriş

Hacklink

bettilt giriş

bettilt giriş

bettilt

betgaranti

betgaranti

bahis forum

bets10

bets10

taraftarium24 izle

supertotobet

bettilt giriş

Hacklink

เว็บตรงเกมสล็อตออนไลน์

Cosplay Ajansı

อุปกรณ์สระว่ายน้ำ

Trbet Giriş

supertotobet

supertotobet

betgaranti

Eros Maç Tv

maxwin

cobra 130 mg

cobra 130

cialis fiyat

casibom

casibom giriş

bettilt giriş

bahiscasino

dedektör

Hacklink

Marsbahis

jojobet giriş

jojobet giriş

jojobet giriş

is car insurance tax deductible

bettilt

küçükçekmece escort

şişli escort

şişli escort

şişli escort

beşiktaş escort

beşiktaş escort

beşiktaş escort

fatih escort

deneme bonusu veren siteler

erotic massage istanbul

bakırköy escort

casibom

fatih escort

Streameast Live

casibom

bestsolaris

casibom giriş

sandviç panel

holiganbet

royalbet

esbet

tarafbet

pusulabet

onwin güncel giriş

hilbet

tulipbet

bullbahis

beinwon

ajaxbet

trwin

parobet

aşk büyüsü

kali linux eğitim

royalbet

casibom güncel giriş

direkturtoto

youngtoto

capitaltoto

pusulabet

prop money

supertotobet

bettilt

Ofis Mobilyaları

cialis fiyat

casibom

casibom giriş

Google Maps Yorum Satın Al

bahiscasino

Capitaltoto

Agen Toto Besar

celtabet

new unblocked games

streameast

speed dating, county, state, city

deneme bonusu

deneme bonusu veren siteler

bonus veren siteler

bonus veren siteler

deneme bonusu siteleri

bahis siteleri 2025

direkturtoto

Hacklink

Hacklink

pusulabet giriş

บาคาร่า

foor love speed dating events foorlove.com speed dating New york atlanta dallas

bettilt

hızlı çekim casino

casinowon

casibom

Betokeys Güncel Giriş

Hacklink

Meritking

Meritking Giriş

Bahiscasino

casibom giriş

ataşehir escort

Mastertoto

Bets10

marsbahis

betsmove

betsmove giriş

Marsbahis

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Hacklink

Ümraniye Eskort

www.eviewporn.com

marjinbet

bahisal

istanbul ucuz eskort

ugslot900

rabbit road casino

Kartal Escort

Betorder

royalbet

vaycasino

bahiscasino

manhood plus

meritking giriş

grandpashabet giriş

marsbahis giriş

matbet giriş

onwin

https://ymarhaba.com/

vaycasino

Payspan Login

GG Convention

deneme bonusu veren siteler

Sex Hattı

royalbet

ptt kargo

ptt kargo takip

Marsbahis

Marsbahis

Marsbahis

deneme bonusu

Kartal escort

meritking

supertotobet

olaycasino giriş

grandpashabet giriş

vbet

jojobet

pusulabet

jojobet

marsbahis

grandpashabet

extrabet

bahiscom

holiganbet

betpuan

holiganbet

meritking güncel giriş

casibom

Süratbet

casibom

Pendik Escort

matbet giriş

deneme bonusu veren siteler

sekabet

meritking giriş

meritking giriş

meritking güncel giriş

lotusbet giriş

betsmove

casibom giriş

bettilt

@seo_cartel in telegram – seo backlinks, bulk link posting, boost seo ranking

royalbet

galabet

bahiscasino